View Single Post

  #2 (permalink)  
Old 02-26-2007
muris
ROOKIE
muris is offline
 

Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 1
$F: 12,113
Bank: 5,000
Total $F: 17,113
Donate
Rep Power: 0
muris is on a distinguished road
Definitely SS.
1. The molecule structure of steel is more uniformed than aluminum so forces (recoil) are going to be distributed more uniformly.
2. The steel is twice as strong as aluminum and you need up to two times less space for steel design. Design does not have to be compromised for additional space like with aluminum.
3. Aluminum reacts with steel when is in contact with it for longer and looses its structure and mass (similar to corrosion). I’m sure designers have the way to avoid this but when there is steel-steel combination it is going to have no issues for sure.
4. The most important – aluminum heats up much faster and melts at much lower temperature – in most cases we are not going to see the difference but sometimes there are extreme conditions (fire exposure, long lasting exchange) when this can be crucial factor.
See table:

Metal: Steel Thermal Conductivity: 52; Melting Point: 1500(°C)
Metal: Aluminum Thermal Conductivity: 190; Melting Point: 620 (°C)

I see no points to support aluminum – maybe cost, but I think choosing SS over Alum. is well spent money.